How a Shareholders’ Agreement can help a small business weather an early shareholder dispute

A shareholders’ agreement is an essential instrument for any company with multiple shareholders. It is particularly crucial for small, closely-held businesses as it not only governs long-term contingencies but also acts as a critical asset in the short term. This document is the linchpin that can keep a business afloat, helping it navigate through the choppy waters of early-stage disagreements and shareholder disputes.

In the context of the Canadian economy, where small businesses constitute a significant portion—like in Nova Scotia, where over 30,000 businesses are operational, and 90% are classified as small—these agreements become even more essential. Typically, small businesses originate from the vision and hard work of an individual entrepreneur who, after setting the groundwork, may invite friends and family to participate. This is where the shareholders’ agreement becomes pivotal, as it can safeguard the business against the complexity of mixing personal relationships with professional undertakings.

The importance of a shareholders’ agreement cannot be overstated during the formative years of a business. Statistically, these initial years are fraught with the highest risk of failure, putting investments of time, money, and personal assets at stake. The strain of this period can strain or alter personal relationships, leading to unexpected disputes among shareholders. If not adequately addressed, such disagreements can halt business operations, damage the company’s reputation, and lead to its downfall.

To prevent such outcomes, a well-drafted shareholders’ agreement should include several fundamental sections, each addressing key aspects of the business’s operations and shareholder relations:

Roles and Responsibilities of Shareholders: This section delineates the expectations from each shareholder, their roles in management, and operational involvement. It can also outline the board of directors’ structure, how they are elected, and their powers.
Compensation: This addresses if and how shareholders will be compensated for their roles in the company, potentially differentiating between shareholder contributions and employment roles.
Decision-Making Processes: It stipulates how decisions are made, detailing the processes for routine decisions and those requiring a special resolution. It may also outline dispute resolution mechanisms to avoid deadlocks.

Dividends and Distribution Policies: It includes policies on how profits will be distributed, whether through dividends or reinvestments into the company.
Transfer Restrictions: This section outlines any restrictions on the sale or transfer of shares, such as pre-emptive rights, rights of first refusal, or drag-along and tag-along rights.

Exit Strategies and Buyout Agreements: The agreement may provide for various scenarios in which shareholders may exit, including buyout clauses, shotgun clauses, and cross-purchase agreements.

Valuation: Here, the method for valuing shares in the event of a sale or transfer is determined, which is critical for buyout scenarios or when new investors come on board.

Non-Compete and Confidentiality: Shareholders may be required to agree to non-compete clauses that restrict their ability to engage in competing businesses, along with confidentiality agreements to protect proprietary information.

Dispute Resolution: This crucial section outlines the steps for resolving disputes among shareholders, which may include mediation or arbitration processes.

Succession Planning: Provisions for the death or incapacity of a shareholder, including life insurance policies and buy-sell agreements, are considered here.

Each section of the shareholders’ agreement is designed to provide a comprehensive roadmap for how the company will be managed and how various situations will be handled. By addressing issues such as governance, finance, operations, and conflict resolution upfront, the shareholders’ agreement helps ensure that the business can weather internal disputes and continue to operate effectively.

Finally, while a shareholders’ agreement is a vital tool, it is not a panacea and cannot predict every possible scenario. It should be crafted with the understanding that it may need to evolve as the company grows

From the very beginning of our professional relationship, Garnet demonstrated a level of expertise and commitment that immediately put me at ease. His guidance throughout the intricate process of incorporating my business was nothing short of impeccable. What truly sets Garnet apart is his unwavering dedication to his clients. His responses to my inquiries were consistently timely, and his availability ensured that I always felt supported and prioritized.

Garnet has been a real asset to my company. He is a pleasure to work with and more importantly he gets the job done, on time and on budget, so I can focus on growing my business.

I highly recommend Garnet Brooks for company incorporation services. His seamless and efficient process made the incorporation experience effortless. Garnet demonstrates exceptional willingness to assist and promptly answers any questions, making the entire process straightforward and stress-free.

Garnet, and his team made incorporating my small business incredibly simple. I couldn't recommend his service and expertise enough.

When you work with Garnet, you get much more than a lawyer, you get a trusted team member who truly cares about your success day in and day out, and you can count on that year after year.

Garnet has been a key trusted resource for my business. He is a reliable and detail-oriented professional, and his passion to help entrepreneurs shines through in his work.